Villa Monte Pizzeria & Restaurant: Authentic Italian Cuisine in Staten Island

As someone who reviews a lot of local businesses, I can confidently say Gino’s Villa Monte Pizzeria sets the standard for what a neighborhood restaurant should be. Longevity like this doesn’t happen by chance it’s earned through consistency, attention to detail, and doing things the right way every single day. The staff is always welcoming, professional, and efficient. You’re greeted promptly, orders are handled smoothly, and the overall experience feels organized and intentional. There’s a clear pride in how this place is run, and it shows from start to finish. The food is where they truly shine. Fresh ingredients, classic flavors, and dependable execution every time. Whether you’re dining in or taking out, the quality never changes everything arrives hot, fresh, and exactly as expected. No off days, no inconsistency, no surprises. That level of reliability is rare and incredibly valuable in a local spot. The atmosphere is comfortable and inviting, making it an easy choice for families, regulars, and anyone looking for a solid, trustworthy place to eat. This is the kind of restaurant locals rely on, not just visit once. If you’re looking for a place that delivers the same high-quality food and service visit after visit, this is it. Gino’s Villa Monte is a true community staple and an easy recommendation from someone who doesn’t give five stars lightly.

I'm am a Field Supervisor for Snow Operations from Oregon. Calle in to help with the storm. Haven't had a real meal in days, just going nonstop to get people on the roads and to their jobs. Was recommended this place by local plow guy Nicky. "I said I want no BS strait up best pie in NYC!" And here I was sent. First off service was phenomenal! Quick great attitudes, even impressed me from the West coast But for real, Owner just gave me a slice immediately. Because of who I was, and the help I was trying to bring everyone in pure chaos. Got 5 slices al different..and I'm currently eating the last piece on the beach at Great Kills park (awesome place also) Much love from, Riley Oregon guy blown away!! What is that last slice? OMFG

My family can not say enough about Villa Montes. There is nowhere else that you can get the quality and quantity of food at prices that are affordable. Augie and Phil are very generous and take good care of all their customers. I guarantee you will agree once you give them a try. Love u guys.

Grabbed pizza at Gino's Villa Monte and it was a solid Staten Island classic. The plain slice and pesto pie were fresh, cheesy, and flavorful—sauce has that perfect tangy kick. Portions are generous, and everything tasted homemade. Service was excellent: staff super friendly, quick, and welcoming even when busy. Atmosphere is your typical no-frills pizzeria—clean, casual, good for dine-in or takeout, but nothing fancy. Great value and reliable spot for a quick pie or Italian meal!

Best fettuccine Alfredo I’ve ever had. Hands down. The pesto pan pizza here was surprisingly delicious as well! I ordered delivery from their website, therefore can’t comment on the restaurant’s atmosphere… But, Delivery guy was very nice and the order came in 20 minutes after I ordered.

We love their chicken marsala on garlic bread hero! Its sooo good! Pizza is just average ny pizza. We also love their brocolli appetizer its really soft garlicy and buttery

I finally braved it out post-Arctic blast to have a late lunch at old-school Italian, Villa Monte, in New Springville. They have a huge menu and lots of different dishes to choose from. We started with shrimp oreganata and then had a vodka pie which was huge - but always happy to have leftovers. Food and service were both very good!

One of the best pizza parlors in NYC, and a good Italian restaurant. They don't do much for atmosphere because they can't. It is full all the time with people waiting by the counter, and the restaurant side mostly is full every night. Prices are very reasonable, unlike most Italian restaurants. The pizza food is where this place rests easy very high. Slices of all kinds, with my favorite being a round pie buffalo. The rolls are huge and well cooked, pin wheels are flavorful and typically crispy, and the calzones are giant sized. The cheese slice is among the best for the judges out there. Food lovers though would tour their counter top. We are regulars.